[Too Cold NB1.8T]

Had he gone to the dealership, whether or not the car would have been considered a total loss based on the VW dealers parts/repair cost, well this would depend on a number of things:

1. whether or not the accident was his fault.

2. Which insurance company he has and what type of discount they have arranged with that dealership for parts & repairs.

3. The level of his ability in dealing with these matters and the people involved.

People who are highly schooled in the automotive world can "usually" make sound decisions when it comes to dealing with service and parts vendors outside of the dealership, however, people that are not in the "Automotive Know" should stick with the safer bet which is OEM parts & service centers, period.

Many times it comes down to, pay me now or pay me MORE later, in time, money and aggravation.

This is a general statement, not directed at anyone in particular

Food For Thought: If your going to buy a car, buy one that you can afford to maintain properly, there are no short cuts or free lunchs here, choosing to save money over optimum/proper car care is a choice your likely to pay for sooner or later.